The Knight Watch – Alta Wind and the Anatomy of a Tax Refund Case: Lessons in Evidence, Valuation and Controversy Strategy
Tax attorneys Jim Dawson and Leif Anderson published a Knight Watch column in TAXES – The Tax Magazine breaking down lessons learned from the U.S. Court of Federal Claims' Alta Wind decision. The case, encompassing a dispute that spanned more than a decade, addressed questions about how to value wind energy facilities and what evidentiary burdens taxpayers must bear when claiming tax credits under Section 1603 of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. Jim and Leif characterize the litigation as "a tale about the importance of developing the factual record in valuation disputes," and their article delves into the court's burden of proof standard, analysis of purchase price allocation methodologies to intangible and tangible assets, and overall factual support presented by each side. They then turn to key takeaways for taxpayers and tax counsel, namely the importance of developing a strong evidentiary record in valuation disputes through observable market data, careful documentation and cost segregation studies. The piece offers a valuable overview of how taxpayers, renewable energy tax practitioners and tax litigators alike should approach valuation mechanisms and disputes to position themselves for favorable outcomes before the court.
Jim and Leif also co-authored a Holland & Knight alert when the ruling first came out.